TeenTix Logo
Login
Sign Up

Love or Alone

By Oliver Clements, TeenTix KC Press Corps Member

Last Five Years Photo

A decade after they first performed it as their debut as a professional theater company, MTKC returns with The Last Five Years. Sarah Cline and Anthony Fortino reprise their original roles as Cathy and Jamie, bringing the production full circle ten years later.

The first thing you notice when you watch the musical The Last Five Years is that the characters don’t talk to each other.

The Last Five Years follows a broken couple, Jamie played by Anthony Fortino and Cathy played by Sarah Cline. The musical features only two performers. Normally when a play or musical only has two actors, they spend the entire time playing off each other. In this show they share only one short seven-minute scene with each other. Not only are the actors separated physically but they are also separated chronologically. The writing leans deep into non-linear storytelling. All of Cathy’s scenes are portrayed in reverse chronological order. Right after Jamie sings about meeting Cathy for the first time, Cathy mourns the death of their marriage. You feel a strong friction with every new song as we shift timeframes. These people are always at separate stages in life. It is quite the brilliant feat to tell a story about a couple who spend the majority of their time together and be able to tell it in such a way that they not only seem like very separate people but also spend virtually no time on stage together.

While the actors sing by themselves, they are never truly alone. They are surrounded by the orchestra and lighting designed by Brad Hull, which create more than just a backdrop for the actors. In most musicals I see, these elements serve to reflect the emotions the characters are feeling or create an atmosphere for them to inhabit. In this production, these elements each seemed like their own characters that reacted to what the actors did. The actors don’t have another actor on stage to play off of, but they still have a character to play off of. Their counterparts may be physically absent, but all the elements together allow you to see the conversations taking place. At times the orchestra will pause and listen and at times it directly responds to what the actors say. The lights shift to respond to what the characters say as opposed to reflecting what they say. Without these aspects, the story would seem incomplete, but the orchestra and lighting design do a masterful job. Despite all this, it doesn’t change how alone the characters on stage are.

Jamie and Cathy do not end up being right for each other. I knew this from the first song but despite this, it took a while for me to understand that this wasn’t a love story. Love stories are about two people. In this story, for the majority of it, there is only ever one person at a time. You see Fortino and Cline talking to each other but their counterpart is never really there to talk to. While the non-linear structure is a bit unorthodox, it is one of the most important tools used to show how truly separate these characters are. It is not an easy thing to separate the stories of people who spend all their time together. You see the end of Cathy’s story and the beginning of Jamie’s story from the start, but they are still different stories. If they weren’t, I wouldn’t anticipate the end of Jamie's story and the beginning of Cathy’s as I did.